Skip to main content
deleted 185 characters in body
Source Link
Marthaª
  • 33k
  • 27
  • 50

As I've said before, general reference means that there is a type of reference source that is specifically designed to answer that type of question. The list is actually pretty limited: dictionary, thesaurus, and encyclopedia.

Note, for example, that there isn't a standard place to look up "is this grammatical" types of questions, so even the simplest question of that type is not, strictly speaking, general reference.

I don't know if we want to endorse particular dictionaries or encyclopedias. Perhaps we could do something like:

If there is a standard type of reference source specifically designed to answer your question, then it is off-topic here. For example, the definition of a word should be looked up in a dictionary.

Or we could get more specific:

If there is a standard type of reference source specifically designed to answer your question, then it is off-topic here. TheFor the definition of a word, you should be looked uplook in a dictionary; for synonyms and antonyms, you should look in a thesaurus; and for explanation of basic language concepts (grammar terms, parts of speech, etc.), you should look in an encyclopedia.

(I don't like the sudden switch from passive to personal, but I don't have time to come up with anything better right now. Please feel free to edit/comment if you've got better ideas.)

As I've said before, general reference means that there is a type of reference source that is specifically designed to answer that type of question. The list is actually pretty limited: dictionary, thesaurus, and encyclopedia.

Note, for example, that there isn't a standard place to look up "is this grammatical" types of questions, so even the simplest question of that type is not, strictly speaking, general reference.

I don't know if we want to endorse particular dictionaries or encyclopedias. Perhaps we could do something like:

If there is a standard type of reference source specifically designed to answer your question, then it is off-topic here. For example, the definition of a word should be looked up in a dictionary.

Or we could get more specific:

If there is a standard type of reference source specifically designed to answer your question, then it is off-topic here. The definition of a word should be looked up in a dictionary; for synonyms and antonyms, you should look in a thesaurus; and for explanation of basic language concepts (grammar terms, parts of speech, etc.), you should look in an encyclopedia.

(I don't like the sudden switch from passive to personal, but I don't have time to come up with anything better right now. Please feel free to edit/comment if you've got better ideas.)

As I've said before, general reference means that there is a type of reference source that is specifically designed to answer that type of question. The list is actually pretty limited: dictionary, thesaurus, and encyclopedia.

Note, for example, that there isn't a standard place to look up "is this grammatical" types of questions, so even the simplest question of that type is not, strictly speaking, general reference.

I don't know if we want to endorse particular dictionaries or encyclopedias. Perhaps we could do something like:

If there is a standard type of reference source specifically designed to answer your question, then it is off-topic here. For example, the definition of a word should be looked up in a dictionary.

Or we could get more specific:

If there is a standard type of reference source specifically designed to answer your question, then it is off-topic here. For the definition of a word, you should look in a dictionary; for synonyms and antonyms, you should look in a thesaurus; and for explanation of basic language concepts (grammar terms, parts of speech, etc.), you should look in an encyclopedia.

Source Link
Marthaª
  • 33k
  • 27
  • 50

As I've said before, general reference means that there is a type of reference source that is specifically designed to answer that type of question. The list is actually pretty limited: dictionary, thesaurus, and encyclopedia.

Note, for example, that there isn't a standard place to look up "is this grammatical" types of questions, so even the simplest question of that type is not, strictly speaking, general reference.

I don't know if we want to endorse particular dictionaries or encyclopedias. Perhaps we could do something like:

If there is a standard type of reference source specifically designed to answer your question, then it is off-topic here. For example, the definition of a word should be looked up in a dictionary.

Or we could get more specific:

If there is a standard type of reference source specifically designed to answer your question, then it is off-topic here. The definition of a word should be looked up in a dictionary; for synonyms and antonyms, you should look in a thesaurus; and for explanation of basic language concepts (grammar terms, parts of speech, etc.), you should look in an encyclopedia.

(I don't like the sudden switch from passive to personal, but I don't have time to come up with anything better right now. Please feel free to edit/comment if you've got better ideas.)