This question, The meaning of "did not immediately respond to requests for comment" [closed], was closed by the following users, in this order:

Janus Bahs Jacquet, tchrist♦, Rory Alsop, user66974, FumbleFingers

What's tchrist♦ doing in the middle? I thought that when mods decided to close a question, their vote was binding?

From the help:

Moderator votes are binding. Any place we have voting — close, open, delete, undelete, offensive, migration, etc — that vote will reach the threshold and take effect immediately if a single moderator casts a vote.

How has this happened?


Moderators can't cast non-binding votes.

Before moderators were moderators, their votes were ordinary votes and listed in exactly the same way as other votes (that is, in the order received).

When a moderator is elected, every mention of their name gains a diamond. Having existing comments and votes suddenly gaining a diamond is something which candidates [should] consider when running for election.

In that list of users, you can see that "user66974" isn't actually a user. This is the same mechanism: the account which was active in July 2014 isn't now, and every mention of it now bears its generic ID.

I believe that by the same token, if a moderator gives up that role, the diamond is removed from every mention of their name: this could result in questions appearing to have been closed by fewer than five votes with no mention of why that happened (which the diamond would explain).

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .