Bronze for 10, silver for 25, gold for 100? I had a notion that there used to be such badges, but I can't be sure.
I suppose this could use migration to MSO, but let's see what others think.– RegDwigнtJul 30, 2011 at 13:21
1Do we really need more badges? Really?– RobustoJul 30, 2011 at 14:18
I think it has been stated that it is fine to ask such questions on a meta site that is not MSO.– apadernoJul 30, 2011 at 14:56
1Previously discussed and declined at meta.stackexchange.com/questions/45580/….– waiwai933Jul 30, 2011 at 15:32
This is a discussion; does status-declined have any meaning?– apadernoJul 30, 2011 at 15:40
There is already a silver badge for 10 comments that have been up-voted 5 times. It is a silver badge because it's not easy to get at least 5 up-votes on 10 different comments, and that can be classified as "longer term goal."
The equivalent bronze badge is Commentator.
There are no gold badges because comments are second class citizens; badges that would have the effect of increasing the number of comments (which is what I saw happening in some cases in some SE sites) would not have a good effect on an SE site, as questions and answers are the main focus. Between questions and answers, it's then the answers that have more importance.
This question has already been asked twice at MSO, look at the following:
More badges for comments / Bronze and gold versions of “Pundit”
Can we have a badge for up-voted comments?
This request has already been rejected twice, but it's still a good idea. I reckon if we had more support for this proposal, it might come into being.