10

If someone edits your post, it appears under the "Responses" activity stream on your profile, but doesn't trigger an inbox notification. Should it? I for one would like to know if someone's editing something I wrote, without having to check my profile all the time. I know edits are generally minor and done in good faith, but sometimes they have the potential to unintentionally change the author's intent/meaning.

  • 2
    I think it should invariably be notified. Sometimes the edits may even change the post significantly, so much so that some existing answers can become irrelevant, etc., changing the whole scenario. This has happened in a few instances I have seen. If the OP fails to notice, he may even continue to post comments that do not agree with his own question any more. – Kris Dec 30 '11 at 5:02
1

I'm not generally in favor of aggressive edit notifications because I think it leads directly to edit wars.

Most edits we see are quite small and it is extraordinarily rare for an edit to cause issues as you describe.

And as you noted, you can periodically check your profile to see what edits have occurred on your posts, and take action as you see fit.

  • +1 The convenience would not be worth the strife. – Daniel Jan 22 '12 at 1:50

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .