Please have a look at Is “sparkle” the correct word? The question consists of asking if the right word was used, with nothing said about the goals the writer wants to achieve. (We require that for critique questions.) We received this on Writers this morning.
I closed it as vague, and I'd like to know why the question was sent to us? This is not a critique question, it's just a vague, unclear question tagged "critique".
Edit: The question has been clarified a bit and re-opened on Writers.