In this question
The question was initially badly phrased asking for words meaning something that really does defy physics. Initial answers then quite rightly gave answers like 'supernatural', while also pointing out that 'defying physics' wasn't really what was happening.
Later edits by the OP show that these really weren't the answers he's looking for, because he wasn't wanting a deference to magic.
I've since edited the question to reframe it as 'appearing to defy physics', but this invalidates the other three answers.
Personally I think what should have happened was the original answerers should have edited the question straight away. Given that that hasn't happened, is my edit the best course of action, or is it better to close the question and ask a new one?