17

I just asked a question which was slightly different from what I intended to ask in the first place. Now there are 4-5 valid answers. What should I do now? Re-ask the question, or edit my question to what I intended?

The real reason I'm asking this is that I think editing the question would be disrespectful to the people who answered my original question, because their answers are valid.

18

Where there are a number of valid answers, you are right that to change the question and invalidate them would not be a good thing to do.

Indeed, it's not a good thing when there are any answers, but at least when there is only one it's fairly easy to add a comment apologising and noting that the question has changed. Hopefully that will stave off any downvotes the answer might attract because it doesn't answer the question which later visitors see.

The best thing to do is to ask a new question in which you can link to your original. You may even be able to ask in such a way as to value the existing answers. "This was useful because it showed X. However, what I actually wanted to know was Y, and the answers don't cover that as I can't apply X because of Z," or something.

Actually, the best thing to do is to ask the right question in the first place. Take time to write it; make sure that there is no ambiguity at all. Do some research yourself, including looking for generalised keywords here which may be related to your query: and present your research in the question. You may find the answer to your query [in which case, upvote the post(s) as they've been useful] or you may be able to build on someone else's post and you can link to it for background.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .